Broil King 923617 Smoker Review
Our verdict
The Broil King 923617 is a natural gas smoker built from a combination of aluminum, stainless steel, and steel, weighing 73 lb at $599. With only 12 reviews the data is thin, but the 4.6 average from those buyers is promising for cooks who want the convenience of a gas line connection.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Homeowners with a natural gas hookup who want a permanent patio smoker without the hassle of propane tank refills or charcoal management.
Skip if
You do not have a natural gas line at your patio, want portability, prefer charcoal smoke flavor, or need more buyer reviews before committing.
- Fuel Natural Gas
- Material Aluminum,Stainless Steel,Steel
- Color Black
- Weight 73.0 lb
- Priced 82% above the category median ($329.50 across 122 tracked models)
Pros
- Natural gas connection means no refills and consistent fuel supply
- Mixed stainless steel and aluminum construction offers good corrosion resistance
- 73 lb weight is manageable compared to heavy charcoal smokers
- 4.6 rating from buyers, though a small sample, is encouraging
Cons
- Only 12 reviews makes the rating statistically thin
- Requires a natural gas line, limiting placement to homes with patio gas hookups
- No cooking area or BTU spec listed in available data
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.6/5
4.6 average across 12 owner ratings
-
Popularity0.7/5
12 owner reviews, fewer than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other grills, grill parts and burners, smokers and smoking gear, grill tools, outdoor griddles, outdoor kitchen appliances and grill covers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
['Natural gas as a fuel source means this Broil King connects to a home gas line and runs indefinitely without swapping tanks or managing charcoal. Temperature control on natural gas smokers is dial-based, which removes much of the fire-management guesswork. That makes it a convenient option for cooks who want smoke flavor without the hands-on intensity of charcoal.', 'The mixed material construction, aluminum, stainless steel, and steel, at 73 lb gives the unit some substance without being as heavy as all-steel competition in this category. At 599 dollars it sits in the mid-range for gas-fueled smokers. Stainless steel components in the mix will hold up well outdoors, while aluminum adds corrosion resistance in other areas.', "The 4.6 rating is strong, but 12 reviews is a very small sample. Buyers should treat this score as directional rather than statistically significant. Research Broil King's customer service and warranty policies before purchasing, as the brand matters more when review volume is this low."]
Specifications
| Fuel | Natural Gas |
|---|---|
| Material | Aluminum,Stainless Steel,Steel |
| Color | Black |
| Weight | 73.0 lb |
Performance notes
Fuel type is natural gas, which provides consistent, adjustable heat via a burner connected to a home gas supply. Temperature management is more precise and easier to sustain than charcoal. The unit weighs 73 lb and uses a combination of aluminum, stainless steel, and regular steel in its construction. Aluminum resists corrosion well; stainless steel adds durability at contact points. No BTU or cooking area figure is published in available specs. No dimensions are listed, so physical footprint planning should involve checking the product page directly.
What buyers say
With only 12 reviews averaging 4.6 out of 5, the sample is too small to draw firm conclusions. The high score could reflect genuine quality or a self-selection bias among early buyers who are enthusiastic. Buyers considering this model at $599 would benefit from seeking out additional third-party reviews or forum discussions about Broil King's natural gas smoker lineup before purchasing.
Similar grills, grill parts and burners, smokers and smoking gear, grill tools, outdoor griddles, outdoor kitchen appliances and grill covers to consider
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a special connector to hook up a natural gas smoker?
Natural gas smokers require a dedicated gas line at your patio with a shutoff valve and compatible fitting. Most units come with a connector hose, but you will need a licensed plumber or gas technician to install the line if one does not already exist. This is a one-time setup cost that pays off in long-term convenience.
How does natural gas smoke flavor compare to charcoal?
Natural gas itself does not produce smoke flavor. The smoke comes from wood chips or chunks you add to a smoke box or tray in the smoker. The gas burner provides the heat; the wood provides the smoke. This gives you reasonable control over smoke intensity by adjusting how much wood you add and how often.